the other school of economics

Prince Sarkozy

French politics, journalism, new media, irreverence… all in one post.
Revisting what is actually left of the mainstream debate around Sarkozy.

Martians and non-French speaking internet travellers might have noticed the proliferation of a curious set of tags: #sarkozy #nicolassarkozyeverywhere (nicolas sarkozy everywhere) as well as the recently uber-trending #jeansarkozypartout (jean sarkozy everywhere).
They are a digital tribute to the French omni-hyper-president and a celebration of his management style, which has developed over the years from his debut as Jacques Chirac’s protégé – before betraying him – to Minister of Interior an finally President.
Sarkozy’s story is interesting as the man does not necessarily convey a sense of Machiavellian puppeteer crafting his web of power behind the scene. He rather resembles the caricature of the used-car salesman: not very brainy, a bit rough with his manners, a bit ‘nouveau riche’, fascinated by the attributes of wealth (trophy wife, powerful friends in the Top End of town, jet set life and all the perks that come with it)

sarkozy_bruni

Nicolas & Carla: give the plebe a bit of soap opera content – source

A few years before his election he was perceived as the ultimate looser and traitor in politics (having backed a losing opponent to Chirac).
So how did he manage to make such a come back and get elected? And how is he managing to stick to his position?

The comeback: playing the populist card is always a short term wining strategy.

To cut it short, he belongs, alongside George W Bush and Silvio Berlusconi, to a breed of conservative politicians treated with contempt by their liberal (in the American sense of the word) and labour opponents, who manage to appeal to the mainstream and have succeeded in blurring the traditional divide Left-Right. They have courted the middle class with the traditional values of the right (law, order, and everyone in bed by 9pm…) sprinkled with some modern day bits of consumerism: work hard, accept the laws corporate-capitalism, get informed through the mainstream media “and we’ll all right…”
In France the programmed acceptance of the laws of corporate-capitalism have been derailed by the Credit Crisis, which has forced Sarkozy to declare his famous “Le Laissez-Faire, c’est fini / The Laissez-faire is over”. The reason was that a little bit of social veneer had to be incorporated into the political communication to appease the public opinion as the collapse of the financial markets turned into an economic crisis..
The other layer of veneer applied in his government was to open it to a certain form of bi-partisanship and enrol Labour (Socialistes) figures as ministers.

However the core of the conservative agenda and more importantly the permanent arm-twisting of the media have not gone away from Sarkozy’s program.

It is the relationship with, and usage of, the media that is of particular interest here, as it ends-up serving the centre piece of the sarko-paradigm: his ego.
The strategy is based on:
- Appetite for managing the media (direct interference to change the public broadcasting system to suit his views)
- Friendships among the media establishment (close relationship to tabloids and commercial TV channels)
- A strategy to saturate the media leaving little space for the opposition or for the media to cast a more critical eye over the performance of his government. (Enrolment of the ultimate trophy wife: Carla Bruni in the role of First Decoy and alibi with the Left)
Such an hyper-bloated ego who strives on a form of ‘revenge to take on the rest of the system’: this type of angry underdog mentality might be ok for a young-and-up-coming entrepreneur in the silicon valley but is frankly incompatible with the duties of the state-man.

The mind-boggling element of the story is that it is done in whole day light, “au vu et au su de tous” and yet, it seems to have worked. So far.

A recap of a few memorable moments of the Sarko-saga highlighting the various facettes of the issue.

- His conservative ultra-right side.
In Oct-Nov 2005 civil unrest and riots spread across poor housing projects (cités HLM) in various parts of France. A series of riots involving mainly the burning of cars and public buildings went on for 20 nights.
Whilst the root cause of these events was the tension building up among the juvenile population, the behaviour of the then Minister of interior (hence Chief Cop) did not appease things. Quite the the contrary he seemed to entertain a certain “strategy of tension” by using a tough semantics towards the youth, in order to indicate to the mainstream voters that we would tackle the problem head-on and sanitise the suburbs from the scum (racaille) that was growing there.
This stand proved to be a very useful asset to get the votes of the ultra-right a few years later at the presidential election.

banlieue

Sarko-cops

- His moody and erratic behaviour.
The potential psychological issues that Sarkozy faces have been highlighted well before the 2007 presidential campaign. His swinging moods, hyper-activity, latent aggressiveness, and perpetual need try hard to prove himself have been well documented by a range of people who got to know him. However it was always going to be an interesting moment of truth when the know issues would surface on the public stage.
A most memorable moment remains the “casse-toi pauvre con” (literally: “Fuck-you, poor jerk”) given off-the-cuff to the visitor of an agricultural show who refused to shake the presidential hand. People will appreciate the consensual nature of the intervention.

sarkozy_casse_toi_pauvre_co

short and sweet: to the point.

- The control of the media is an on going saga, too rich and too long for this post.
Direct intimidation, pressure to sack journalists who would report on him in a manner he does not appreciate, suing.
Maybe the best way to grasp the issue is to compare the subservient attitude of the French media with the standard treatment given to the Australian PM on ABC’s 7:30 Report or Lateline.
We are talking about two different worlds: On the French side, the prepared questions, the platitudes, the lack of incisiveness, are absolutely appalling. This is more a monarch dealing with the court than an elected president accountable in front of the media.

ABC-730report

John Howard grilled by Kerry O’Brien on ABC’s 7:30 report

sarkozy-press-fr

sarkozy-ferrari-pujadas-5-fev-2009.1234434616

Sarkozy interviewed in a parody of journalism by TV anchors vetted and agreed by him

So, all that being said, where is the opposition to Sarkozy?

The question is actually not that irreverent and incongruous for we know that a strong and healthy opposition is actually a service done to democracy and a condition to the success of incumbent government. (Although this view seems to be more accepted in the Anglo-Saxon Westminster system than in French politics).
The Socialist party is clearly not doing its job as main opposition party. The space is left to some elements of the right (democrat party centre-right) and to a fairly new non-mainstream press leveraging social media and citizen journalism.
The most notable outlets are rue89, contre-info, Marianne Magazine, Mediapart. They show that, to their credit, some in the print & online media are actually trying hard.
Contrary to Australia where ABC and SBS fight to maintain a high-standard and independend line (see Julian Morrow’s 2009 Andrew Olle Lecture), it is the television side that is failing miserably in France.
The weapon of choice of those new-media? Rigorous journalism, participative investigation, diversity of contributions, but also humour, irreverence, caricature and laughter to denounce, highlight, reveal, flag the abuse and abuses.

The stories that have entertained us lately are:
- the nomination of Jean Sarkozy – the 23 year old son – at the helm of the agency managing the development of the Paris Business district ‘La Défense’ (Agency’s budget: 115m Euros / La Défense district = 3 350 000 m² of offices, 150,000 employees in 2,500 companies… the kid is 23 and still at Uni) . The total lack of academic and professional qualifications outraged the general population. A petition was launched and Sarko-son was forced to back down. Not without offering himself the mindboggling opportunity to go on the 8pm national news bulletin to comment on his decision not to go for the job.

jeansarko-20h

Monsieur fils offers himself a slice of the evening news on national TV to chat about his job opportunities. fyi, people…

- and a fairly innocuous Facebook update from Sarkozy regarding his whereabouts during the fall of the Berlin Wall. He implied that he was in Berlin the night the Wall fell. It did not take long for a few journalists to confirm that the sarko-claim to have been on the fore front of the event was totally bogus. Sarkozy came to Berlin as the picture attests but only days after the event. The affaire even got a little bit of media coverage abroad (review compiled by @GillesKLEIN).

sarko-berlin

Re-writing history. Re-engraving for that matter.

His obsession to rewrite history and put himself under the spotlights has been a very fertile source of inspiration for citizen cartoonists and caricaturists showing that the Gallic sense of humour is not dead…

in-post-660-200-sarkozypart

There is something ironically Nixon-ian in what comes out Sarkozy’s performance. He has gone beyond the point where people can just disagree with him because they don’t share his political views. His obsession to control the information, his contempt for journalists and his promptness to modify facts to shape his own truth has unfortunately led people to believe that he actually is “a crook”. The difference is that mainstream voters have chosen to either:
- ignore it out of apathy towards a class of politicians that will not reform itself, or
- treat him with laughter

No frontal and political opposition with serious prospect of unseating him has appeared so far.

We’ll keep watching…Good night, and good luck.

iam-not-acrook

i am not a crook

goodnightgoodluck

We will keep watching. Good night, and good luck.

————————————

Coda

- Sarkozy Gallore: the politician who gets photoshopped *INTO* history:

Sarkozy on the Moon – posted by lafillelabas

sarkozy-berlin-moon

Sarkozy at Yalta : posted by Paul

sarkozy-berlin-yalta

Sarkozy knocks the Berlin Wall down : posted by Paul

sarkozy-berlin-wall2

Sarkozy actually invented the MoonWalk : posted by Christophe

sarkozy-berlin-wacko

Sarkozy WAS Mstislav Rostropovich : posted by NKN

sarkozy-berlin-rostro

Sarkozy at the 1968 Mexico Olympics : Posted by NKN

sarkozy-berlin-mexico

Sarkozy was with Martin Luther King : posted by Sandra

sarkozy-berlin-lutherking

Sarkozy actually met Jesus: posted by NKN

sarkozy-berlin-judas

Sarkozy used to be the leader of the Beatles : posted by Gaet

sarkozy-berlin-beatles

Sarkozy was on Apollo 11: posted by JeSuisLa

sarkozy-berlin-apollo

Sarkozy master of the McDonaldisation of politics : posted by woumpah

41772496

- Pipole & tabloid time…

After this dose of fascinating considerations on el President, we should actually connclude in a Shrek-ian manner. Maybe this whole palaver is about love. A simple guy, a bit insecure, a bit shrewd as well, who just wanted to prove everyone that he could get the top job, get the girl from the magazines and aspire to spend some time wearing boxer-shorts on the beach… La vie quoi.

Sarko-Carla-Bruni-Beach

The careful orchestration of paparazzi pictures to entertain the good people, as a strategy to avoid real debate on policy issues

CarlaBruni_620

The ultra-conservative right has had to eat its hat twice: when Sarkozy appointed figures of the left in his government; and when he married Carla Bruni, figure of the Parisian-wealthy-arty-left-scene… in short: everything they loathe.

{ LF_O }

Disseminate:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Blogplay
  • Add to favorites
  • email
  • FriendFeed
  • Identi.ca
  • Netvibes
  • Ping.fm
  • Posterous
  • Reddit
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
  • Wikio
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks

2 Comments

Leave a Reply




  • fidlr

  • fidlr-isms

    http://bradfidler.com/

    Best summarized by this line:
    "A serendipitous juxtaposition, for those who know Brad and for those who should get know him, an intrepid explorer of the spaces between pharmaceuticals, networks, Chinese culture, economics and philosophy."

  • RSS fidler

    • Another Psychiatric Acronym (APA)
      “Aetiology and Ethnicity in Schizophrenia and Other Psychoses” ÆSOP (that’s a study). They used that AE thing. Probably because the study took place in Nottingham and they think like that up there. They discovered that getting good help means you’re less likely to hurt yourself, during your first psychotic episode (a magical time). I really don […]
    • At Least They Didn’t Ask Me The Hard Questions
      This segment was shown on Channel One News, which is either a media-rich pedagogy tool for American high schools, or an advertising delivery vehicle for captive audiences.  The crew, host, and producers were very nice. […]
    • Getting the Internet a Proper Plaque
      Last night, we wrapped up the Fortieth Anniversary of the Internet, an event I co-chaired.  UCLA and Professor Leonard Kleinrock (below) were also awarded a plaque from the IEEE, which I had the honor of helping write: Birthplace of the Internet, 1969 – At 10:30 p.m., 29 October 1969, the first ARPANET [...] […]
  • Paul Kugman

  • RSS Paul Krugman, NYT RSS

    • America Is Not Yet Lost February 9, 2010
      The way the Senate works is no longer consistent with a functioning government, and senators should change the rules to end obstructionism. […]
    • Fiscal Scare Tactics February 9, 2010
      Fear-mongering on the deficit as part of the Republican political strategy could end up doing as much harm as the fear-mongering on weapons of mass destruction. […]
    • Good and Boring February 9, 2010
      We can learn from Canada’s regulatory habit of limiting the risk and leverage banks can accept, which helped protect that country from recessionary fallout. […]
    • March of the Peacocks February 9, 2010
      Our budget problems won’t be solved with gimmicks like a temporary freeze in nondefense discretionary spending. […]
    • The Bernanke Conundrum February 9, 2010
      Ben Bernanke should be reappointed as chairman of the Federal Reserve only because rejecting him could make the Fed’s policies worse. […]
    • Do the Right Thing February 9, 2010
      America desperately needs health care reform; it would be a betrayal of trust if the Democrats simply folded. […]
    • What Didn’t Happen February 9, 2010
      President Obama’s troubles result from misjudgments: the stimulus was too small; banking policy wasn’t tough enough; and he didn’t shelter himself from criticism. […]
    • Bankers Without a Clue February 9, 2010
      Financial system reformers should ignore advice coming from the supposed wise men of Wall Street, whose testimony showed they have no wisdom to offer. […]
    • Learning From Europe February 9, 2010
      Despite what conservatives claim, Europe has a successful economy and a social democracy that works. […]
  • Robert Skidelsky

  • RSS Robert Skidelsky

  • le Laissez-Faire is Over

  • RSS leLaissezFaireisOver

  • the Australia Institute

  • RSS The Australia Institute

    • Between The Lines December February 9, 2010
      'Between the Lines' is The Australia Institute's selective analysis of the policies and politics affecting the wellbeing of Australians. READING BETWEEN THE LINES THIS WEEK: 1. Stop Press: Cooper Review adopts suggestions from The Australia Institute's Submission 2. Macklin's welfare changes—just say 'No'! 3. It's j […]
    • Between The Lines November February 9, 2010
      'Between the Lines' is The Australia Institute's selective analysis of the policies and politics affecting the wellbeing of Australians. READING BETWEEN THE LINES THIS WEEK: 1. National Go Home On Time Day - November 25 2. That other great moral challenge 3. Telemarketing: the lifeblood of commerce NATIONAL GO HOME ON TIME DAY - NOVEMBER 25 […]
    • Between The Lines February 9, 2010
      'Between the Lines' is The Australia Institute’s selective analysis of the policies and politics affecting the wellbeing of Australians. READING BETWEEN THE LINES THIS WEEK: 1. The strange argument for carbon price compensation 2. Buying power stations vs compensating them 3. An uncharitable act 4. Bank profits out of this world THE STRANGE ARGU […]
    • Between The Lines February 9, 2010
      'Between the Lines' is The Australia Institute’s selective analysis of the policies and politics affecting the wellbeing of Australians. READING BETWEEN THE LINES THIS WEEK: The Equity Edition 1. Does the Rudd Government deserve a tick for its stimulus package? 2. Could you live on $228 a week? How Australia compares with the rest of the world […]
  • la vie des idees

  • RSS La Vie des Idées

    • La querelle du relativisme February 9, 2010
      La question du relativisme n'a cessé d'agiter les sciences sociales au cours des dernières années. Ne constituant pas un front homogène, mais plutôt une nébuleuse réunissant sous un même label des démarches différentes, aucune réfutation systématique n'avait pu en être proposée jusqu'ici. C'est cette lacune que propose de combler Pau […]
    • Le mystère de la Terreur February 9, 2010
      Pour l'historien Dan Edelstein, l'épisode violent de la Terreur découle directement de la fascination des révolutionnaires français pour la théorie du droit naturel. Cette nouvelle interprétation n'a pas convaincu Annie Jourdan, qui s'interroge en particulier sur la pertinence d'une analyse de la Révolution française en termes schmit […]
    • Manipulation mentale et dispositif d'État February 9, 2010
      En s'intéressant à ce qui se dit des « sectes » en France, A. Esquerre interroge avec finesse les lieux communs qui sévissent habituellement dans le débat. Il ressort de son analyse que l'accusation de « manipulation mentale » occulte la complexité et la singularité de la situation visée – et notamment le dispositif d'Etat ciblant le psychisme […]
    • La Catalogne et son Statut d'autonomie February 9, 2010
      Le juriste Adrià Mateu analyse le Statut d'autonomie de la Catalogne, de 1979 à sa réforme en 2006, dans la création et dans le développement de l'État espagnol des autonomies. Celui-ci offre un modèle éclectique d'organisation territoriale de l'État, qui combine les propriétés d'un État unitaire et d'un État fédéral. - Idées d […]
    • Catalunya i el seu Estatut d'autonomia February 9, 2010
      Aquest article se centra en el paper de l'Estatut d'Autonomia de Catalunya de 1979 i la seva reforma l'any 2006, en la creació i el desenvolupament de l'estat autonòmic espanyol com a model eclèctic de forma d'organització territorial de l'estat, que combina elements típics de l'estat unitari i de l'estat federal. - I […]
  • .

    ..